UserProof

UserProof / Free tools / Homepage grader

Homepage grader for founders: score your homepage against 378 YC startups

Free tool · runs in your browser · no email · Updated November 15, 2026
TL;DRA free homepage grader for startup founders. Answer 10 checks about your homepage on a phone, the same 10 we ran on 378 YC startup homepages on October 28, 2026, and get a score out of 100 and the fix worth the most points. Half the startups scored 95 or more; 93 of 378 (25%) passed everything. The most missed check: 122 of 366 (33%) had no sign-up or demo button on the first phone screen. No email, and your answers stay in your browser.

For startup founders who want phone visitors to sign up or book a demo: answer the 10 checks below and get a score out of 100, using the same points we gave the 378 YC startups. You also see how many of 378 YC startups scored higher and the fix worth the most. The example below, a page with no button on the first phone screen and a slow load, scores 75; moving the button up makes it 95.

By Ryan Doyle, founder of UserProof, who ran the 378-homepage check this grader compares you with.

Grade your homepage

Open your homepage on a phone (or a 390px-wide phone view in your browser's developer tools) and answer each question. Not sure? Pick "Not sure" and the steps under the grader say how to check it. No sign-up, demo or get-started button anywhere on your homepage? Our scan couldn't score that case (12 of 378), so answer Yes to questions 1 to 4 and add a button first.

The grader needs JavaScript and its script hasn't run, so changing an answer changes nothing here. The result below is the example, worked out in full.

Example result

75 out of 100 · Fair

324 of the 378 YC startup homepages we checked (86%) scored higher, 39 scored the same and 15 (4%) scored lower.

Fix first: move the main button into the first screen on a phone. It is worth 20 points and takes you to 95, where 93 of the 378 scored higher. 67% of the YC startups we could test passed this check.

Your failed checks, in the order to fix them
FixPointsScore afterYC startups that pass
Move the main button into the first screen on a phone+209567% (244 of 366)
Get the load under 4 seconds on a computer and 6 on a phone+510075% (282 of 378)

Every score, and how many YC startups beat it

The 378 YC startup homepages we checked on October 28, 2026, by score. Find your score to see how many scored higher and lower.

Scores of 378 YC startup homepages, October 28, 2026
ScoreStartupsScored higherScored lowerBand
100930 (0%)285 (75%)Good
959993 (25%)186 (49%)Good
9047192 (51%)139 (37%)Good
8511239 (63%)128 (34%)Fair
8074250 (66%)54 (14%)Fair
7539324 (86%)15 (4%)Fair
7012363 (96%)3 (1%)Needs work
652375 (99%)1 (0%)Needs work
551377 (100%)0 (0%)Needs work

The 10 checks and what each is worth

Points lost for each failed check, and how many YC startups failed it, out of the ones where the check could run (the four button checks need a main button to test). The YC report gives the first one as 32% because it divides by all 378; here it is divided by the 366 where we found a main button.

The 10-point homepage checklist with its points and fail rates
ProblemPointsStartups that failedShare
No main button on the first phone screen20122 of 36633%
Main button does nothing252 of 2981%
Main button covered1511 of 2904%
Main button too small to tap595 of 26835%
Wider than a phone100 of 3780%
JavaScript errors519 of 3785%
Broken links513 of 3783%
Dead clicks529 of 3788%
Slow to load596 of 37825%
Images or files fail to load529 of 3788%

What the 378 homepages show

Each startup's own result, with a phone screenshot, is in the YC homepage benchmark.

How to check each one on your own homepage

About 10 minutes in Chrome on a computer. Open the page, press Cmd+Option+I (Ctrl+Shift+I on Windows) for developer tools, then Cmd+Shift+M (Ctrl+Shift+M) for the phone view, then choose Responsive and type 390 by 844, the phone size our scan used.

  1. Button on the first screen: without scrolling, can you see a button or link that says something like "get started", "book a demo", "sign up" or "join the waitlist"? Our scan looked for those words and 40 more; a main action in other words ("copy prompt", "install") counted as no main button.
  2. Button works: tap it once and wait up to 10 seconds. A new page, a new tab, a form, a dialog or a scroll counts.
  3. Nothing covers it: load the page in a private window so the cookie banner and chat bubble appear as a first-time visitor sees them. If either sits on top of the button, the first tap hits them instead.
  4. At least 44px tall: right-click the button, Inspect, and hover it in the Elements panel; the tooltip shows its full size, padding included, which is what the scan measured. 44 is the smallest tap target Apple's design guidelines give.
  5. Fits the phone: try to scroll sideways in the phone view. If the page moves, something is wider than the screen.
  6. No JavaScript errors: reload with the Console tab open. Red errors from files on your own domain count; errors from chat, booking or analytics widgets didn't count in our scan.
  7. No broken links: click each link to your own pages from the homepage. Any 404 fails.
  8. No dead clicks: click everything that looks clickable: cards, icons, logos, underlined text. The dead click finder marks each of your clicks as worked, slow, dead or error, free.
  9. Load time: reload with the Network tab open and read the Load time at the bottom. It should be under 4 seconds on a computer and under 6 in the phone view. Leave throttling at No throttling: our scan used none and timed the page's load event.
  10. Images and files load: in the same Network tab, look for rows in red (a 404, 403 or 500). Each is an image, font or script your page asked for and didn't get.

Where the comparison comes from

The 378 scores are from our check of YC startup homepages from the Winter 2025 to Fall 2026 batches, each loaded in Chromium as a 390px-wide phone and a 1366px-wide desktop on October 28, 2026 (full method). A score starts at 100 and loses the points in the table above for each failed check. A check our scan couldn't run (no main button found) cost nothing, and "Not sure" here works the same way. The grader reads the counts from the 378 published startup pages when it is built and rebuilds when the benchmark is re-run.

Limits

Then see what real visitors do

The grader tells you what a first visit should get right. UserProof shows what actually happens: a free scan of your live site finds broken elements on day one (up to 10 scans a day per site). Once its script records real visits, it counts dead clicks, rage clicks, errors on click and slow responses, then hands your coding agent (Claude Code, Codex or Cursor) the one fix with the file and line. Free for 3 sites and 5,000 recorded visits a month; Pro is $29 a month for 50,000; Scale is $99 for 250,000 (pricing).

Related: the funnel calculator, how many visitors you need to test a change, all free tools.

Sources, read November 15, 2026

Cite this

UserProof, "Homepage grader", https://getuserproof.com/homepage-grader, updated November 15, 2026. Of 378 YC startup homepages checked on October 28, 2026, 93 (25%) passed all 10 checks and 122 of 366 had no sign-up or demo button on the first phone screen; median score 95 of 100.

FAQ

What is a good homepage score?

On these 10 checks, 90 or more is good: 239 of the 378 YC startups (63%) got there. The median was 95. Under 75 puts a homepage in the bottom 4%, and only 15 of the 378 scored that low.

What does the homepage grader check?

It checks what stops a phone visitor from taking the next step. Four are about the main button: it is on the first screen, it works on the first tap, nothing covers it, and it is at least 44px tall. The other six: the page fits the screen, no JavaScript errors from your own code, no broken links, no dead clicks, a load under 4 seconds on a computer and 6 on a phone, and images and files that load. The points are the ones our benchmark used; they add up to 100.

Why does a missing button on the first phone screen cost 20 points?

Because a visitor who never sees the next step can't take it. Our scan used a 390 by 844 phone screen, so a button passes when it starts within the top 844px, and 122 of the 366 YC startups where we found a main button had it below that line. Only a button that does nothing when tapped costs more (25 points), and just 2 of 298 did that.

Can it grade my homepage automatically from a URL?

No. This page fetches nothing; you answer each check after looking at your own page, and the steps below say how to check each one in a few minutes. UserProof's free site scan reads the live site for you once you add it (up to 10 scans a day per site).

Is this a website grader for SEO?

No. SEO graders score titles, tags and backlinks. This one scores whether a visitor on a phone can see and use the button that turns them into a sign-up or a demo, which is what the 10 checks in our benchmark measured.

Does the grader store or send my answers?

No. Its script runs in your browser, makes no requests and saves nothing. The page itself loads fonts and the same visit analytics as the rest of this site, and the form and the result are marked so the recorder skips them.